A mommy, a midwife and an accusation of drugging without approval

Caution: This write-up includes images some viewers could discover troubling.

Jennifer Nosek’s maternity was whatever she had actually expected. After 2 losing the unborn babies, she really felt happy and loosened up as her due day came close to.

In Sayulita, Mexico, her part-time home, she and her pals collected for an infant shower, putting on blossom crowns to commemorate. She cleaned carefully put on infant clothing from her very first kid that had actually been stashed for 6 years.

Nosek, a Canadian publication editor, had actually discovered a midwife to aid her in very early labor at home. Heather Baker was understood in Nosek’s area of Sayulita mommies, and, though Nosek really did not understand it, Baker’s intense protection of birth freedom had actually obtained her an online complying with in the 10s of thousands.

Recalling, Nosek stated, that was the minute everything broke down.

” Every little thing was definitely beautiful up until I allow he or she right into my life,” she stated.

In April, Nosek’s infant passed away throughout an extreme and extremely painful labor that Nosek currently thinks was caused by a white tablet she stated Baker offered her quickly prior to his birth. In an issue she submitted with Mexican district attorneys, she affirms that Baker defined the tablet as a light homeopathic however that it was in fact misoprostol, a pharmaceutical made use of to cause labor.

The medicine, she informed NBC Information, created extreme uterine tightenings that she thinks removed her infant’s supply of oxygen. His government-issued fatality certification checklists “perinatal asphyxia” as the reason of fatality.

Heather Baker. (Courtesy Rene Lamos)Heather Baker. (Courtesy Rene Lamos)

On her internet site, Baker states she isn’t presently going to births personally.

Nosek stated that when she later on faced Baker and asked what she had actually been provided, Baker rejected misbehavior, urging she offered her just the natural herb blue cohosh. Yet Nosek stated the tablet looked similar to one that Baker later on informed her was misoprostol.

Along with her issue in Mexico, Nosek has actually submitted problems with the FBI and the Wisconsin Division of Safety And Security and Specialist Providers, the licensing firm in Baker’s home state, both of which are checking into her cases.

Nosek’s tale spread, initially in the tight-knit Sayulita area and after that outside it, in on the internet maternity teams and midwives’ collectives. Quickly various other customers arised, a lot of whom shared their very own problems concerning Baker.

A minimum of 6, along with a previous pupil, have actually lodged problems versus Baker with the Wisconsin licensing firm, which mentioned her in 2014 for exercising without a permit. A buddy of Nosek’s motivated the ladies in Mexico to submit problems with the firm, which has actually resumed its examination right into Baker.

Several of those customers, like Nosek, state Baker provided a cast or tablet she referred to as a “natural” that they currently presume was a pharmaceutical medicine, based upon the unexpected, solid tightenings that adhered to. A grievance submitted by Baker’s previous pupil stated that on several celebrations, Baker suggested that ladies take the medicine progesterone to delay their labor up until she can join them in Mexico.

NBC Information talked to 10 ladies that state they delivered with Baker, 2 in Wisconsin prior to 2014 and 8 in Mexico in the years given that. 4 of those ladies have actually submitted problems with the state licensing firm. A minimum of 2 of the ladies, along with Nosek, have actually talked to the FBI concerning their experiences.

Baker really did not react to numerous telephone calls or to a checklist of composed inquiries NBC Information sent out looking for remark for this write-up.

On social networks, accounts with the usernames “Heather Baker Midwife” and “heatherbakermidwife,” among which had her picture, sent out “discontinue and desist” messages to Nosek and one more previous customer. Watched by NBC Information, they charge the ladies of making “incorrect and maligning declarations.”

Caroline Clancy, public events policeman with the Milwaukee department of the FBI, decreased to verify the examination, pointing out Justice Division plan.

” As in any kind of provided issue, if costs are submitted, they will at some point end up being an issue of public document,” she composed in a declaration.

John Beard, a speaker for the Wisconsin licensing firm, decreased to address inquiries concerning Baker, pointing out a continuous examination. In a declaration, he stated the state’s “alternatives are restricted” when it involves unlicensed specialists charged of breaking guidelines outside the state and would normally depend upon the regulations of the various other territory.

The Mexican government district attorney’s workplace referred NBC Information’ phone call to its Nayarit department, which really did not react to inquiries. The Sayulita authorities and district attorney’s workplaces really did not return telephone calls looking for remark.

sunrise in Sayulita, Mexico. (Jordan Siemens / Getty Images/Cavan Images RF)sunrise in Sayulita, Mexico. (Jordan Siemens / Getty Images/Cavan Images RF)

For many years, a variety of Americans and Canadians have actually created a tight-knit area in Sayulita, Mexico.

On her website, Baker states she isn’t presently going to births personally, a modification to the website made in April. Yet Nosek wishes to see her had liable.

” I do not also have words for the physical violence that was done to me,” Nosek stated. “I’m mosting likely to invest the remainder of my life attempting to identify exactly how to manage the injury of what occurred.”


When Nosek and her partner, Rene Lemos, an engineer, and their kid, Joaquin, very first shown up in Sayulita, an angling town on the western Mexican shore, in 2021, they signed up with a neighborhood of migrants from the united state and Canada. The web surfers had waves. The foodies had fish tacos. The youngsters had an exterior institution.

And the newbies excited to begin or expand their households with very little clinical treatment had Baker.

Nosek’s very first birth had actually been a cesarean area, which she intended to prevent this moment. Yet she had not been established on a home birth, she informed NBC Information. She was prepared to head to the healthcare facility or perhaps have one more C-section if required. She stated Baker guaranteed her she can move to a medical facility if any kind of troubles occurred.

Generally, midwifery deals with birth as an all-natural procedure in which little treatment is required. The ladies that pick midwives and home births do so, partially, since they desire even more control over their bodies and births.

Nosek stated she was okay with the concept of a holistic medication to progress her labor however would not have actually granted being generated with a pharmaceutical in the house, calling such a strategy “greatly hazardous.”

An experienced midwife revealed alarm system at the claims that somebody in their area would certainly offer medicine without educating their people.

” Exactly how do you have complete freedom if you do not have grant points you’re accepting?” stated Stephanie Mitchell, that is a qualified specialist midwife and the founder of a birth center in Alabama “That resembles the reverse of midwifery treatment.”

Baker herself brought to life 5 kids in the house, she states on her internet site. 4 of her shipments were alone,a practice known as freebirthing In 2019, she released an overview to the method.

” I adhere to the methods of our seniors and forefathers,” she composes on her internet site, “utilizing nature and healthy and balanced foods for beneficial, natural herbs for recovery, along with our instinct, devoid of conditioning by social restraints.”

On an October 2022 podcast, Baker stated Mexico’s notoriously high C-section price was one factor she invested a lot time taking a trip to the nation.

” This is why my heart is particularly around,” she stated.

Her internet site keeps in mind that Baker was educated as a “typical midwife” and has actually been going to births given that 1996. Conventional midwives commonly discover via instructions and usually pick not to end up being certified due to thoughtful, spiritual or individual factors.

In Mexico, typical midwives are normally ladies from country and Native neighborhoods, with expertise gave via generations. While the Mexican federal government does not acknowledge typical midwives as specialist service providers, they have in current years obtained extra lawful acknowledgment and are permitted to attend low-risk births.

In Baker’s home state, Wisconsin, a permit is called for to exercise midwifery.

In 2014, the Wisconsin Division of Safety And Security and Specialist Providers mentioned Baker for breaking the legislation, keeping in mind that she had actually “helped several ladies in maternity and giving birth.”

In an authorized terms, Baker concurred not to exercise midwifery in the state unless she was appropriately accredited, and it’s uncertain whether her operate in Mexico, if it was prepared in Wisconsin, would certainly certify as an offense.

Baker is open concerning the reality that she declines licensure since she sees it as a type of federal government disturbance. “I do not believe federal government ought to be up in our vaginal areas or wombs,” she stated on the 2022 podcast.

Defining herself as a “birthkeeper” on her internet site, Baker stresses using reaction and the setting for solutions. Component of that includes her use natural herbs and natural medication.

In the podcast, Baker stated she brings natural herbs to accelerate labor. “It does not indicate I always utilize them,” she stated. 3 customers, consisting of Nosek, informed NBC Information that Baker suggested blue cohosh, commonly made use of throughout giving birth in Native neighborhoods, to assist motivate their labor.

While blue cohosh can be made use of to cause labor, “it brings possibly major though unusual threats to mommy and infant,” stated Dr. Aviva Romm, a midwife and certified medical professional, that would not talk about Baker particularly. Research Study has found it can trigger a stroke in the unborn child or baby. Though its timing and performance can differ amongst receivers, Romm, that is likewise an herbalist, stated “it does not toss someone right away right into labor the method misoprostol or pitocin can.”

” It’s commonly a slower, step-by-step beginning, over numerous dosages,” she stated.

Misoprostol, known for its role in medication abortion, can also be used to induce labor and address postpartum bleeding. (Anna Moneymaker / Getty Images file)Misoprostol, known for its role in medication abortion, can also be used to induce labor and address postpartum bleeding. (Anna Moneymaker / Getty Images file)

Misoprostol, understood for its duty in drug abortion, can likewise be made use of to cause labor and address postpartum blood loss.

Also if Baker were accredited in Wisconsin, she wouldn’t be allowed to use “prescription medicinal representatives” to cause or increase labor, according to state policies. Yet in Mexico, several medicines, consisting of misoprostol, can often be purchased without prescriptions, and midwives aren’t clearly prevented from supplying them.

Midwives occasionally lug misoprostol in instance of postpartum blood loss. Commonly understood for its duty in drug abortions, it is likewise made use of to cause labor. Yet 3 medical professionals informed NBC Information it is dangerous in scenarios like home births, in which it is harder to keep an eye on fetal heart beats continually. And for people like Nosek that have actually had previous C-sections, the American University of Obstetricians and Gynecologists states, it should not be made use of whatsoever.

Baker’s previous pupil, that asked not to be called for anxiety of consequences to her household, informed NBC Information that she thinks Baker was likewise utilizing it to cause births.

She indicated a 2019 Facebook message she stated Baker sent her in feedback to discovering of a tough birth went to in Sayulita by the pupil alone. NBC Information watched the message, which originates from an account with the username Heather Baker. “If I existed I would certainly have provided her 1/4 miso as a last resource,” she texted, “start contrx to see if that functioned. otherwise after that we understand c sec is the method to go.”


Luciana Suarez. (Courtesy Luciana Suarez)Luciana Suarez. (Courtesy Luciana Suarez)

Baker addresses Luciana Suarez on the day of her labor.

Luciana Suarez, that resides in Sayulita, is just one of the customers that currently examine their births with Baker. In February 2021, when she was approximately 38 weeks expectant, she concurred with Baker’s evaluation that she was obtaining “huge.” Baker drifted the concept of generating labor with natural herbs, Suarez stated, and she consented.

Around 9:20 a.m. on Feb. 16, 2021, Suarez stated, she took fifty percent of what Baker referred to as a holistic tablet. Virtually right away, she stated, she started to have tightenings. After she took the 2nd fifty percent, they ended up being hostile, she stated, with virtually no break in between them.

As she started to press, her child’s shoulders ended up being embeded her birth canal, a harmful emergency situation called shoulder dystocia. Baker took care of to displace the infant, Suarez stated, that endured.

That week, Suarez stated, she informed a neighborhood midwife assisting with the infant’s birth documentation that Baker had actually generated her distribution.

When she defined what occurred, the midwife expanded worried. She asked Suarez whether Baker had actually provided her a white tablet. She was specific a natural herb or a homeopathic would not function so swiftly.

Luciana Suarez with her baby (Courtesy Luciana Suarez)Luciana Suarez with her baby (Courtesy Luciana Suarez)

Luciana Suarez with her child.

” I recognized she was right at that time, however I never ever studied it, and I never ever wondered about Heather,” Suarez stated. “I believe I was terrified and daunted since everyone else in the area liked her a lot, and I really did not wish to be the just one that had this truly s —– point that occurred to them.”

Misoprostol isn’t the only pharmaceutical drug Baker is charged of utilizing, according to the Wisconsin licensing firm problems. A confidential customer and Baker’s previous pupil declare that she suggested progesterone to delay shipments.

One more customer, Becky Whitmore, stated in a meeting that when she entered into labor at 40 weeks in 2019, Baker advised her to take progesterone so she can participate in the birth. In a Facebook message to her pupil watched by NBC Information, Baker stated she really hoped the medication would certainly “hold off” the birth for 30 hours, adequate time for her to take a trip to Mexico.

2 OB-GYNs and a professional midwife revealed alarm system at the supposed treatment in meetings.

” Progesterone is never ever made use of to attempt to delay full-term labor,” stated Dr. Kate McLean, a board accredited OB-GYN in Washington state. “That’s nothing that we do.”

Robin Benedict. (Courtesy Robin Benedict)Robin Benedict. (Courtesy Robin Benedict)

Robin Benedict, her companion Allan Spencer, and their child.

Heather Baker with Robin Benedict's baby. (Courtesy Robin Benedict)Heather Baker with Robin Benedict's baby. (Courtesy Robin Benedict)

Heather Baker with Robin Benedict’s infant.

Robin Benedict, one more customer in Mexico that states Baker recommended her to take progesterone, stated she had a tough birth in 2021, calling for that Baker resuscitate her child.

Both Suarez and Benedict submitted problems with the state of Wisconsin after finding out of Nosek’s claims and reconsidering their very own experiences. The problems are still under evaluation.

” Recalling,” Suarez composed in her issue. “I can not cover my mind around exactly how unsafe everything was.”


As waves collapsed behind her, Jennifer Nosek stooped in the sand in late March while the professional photographer’s cam clicked. Grinning, she positioned in a black chopped container exposing her expectant stomach.

The birth was just weeks away. They had actually mounted a safety seat and picked a checklist of prospective infant names.

On April 8, Lemos paid Baker a $2,000 down payment using PayPal.

Jennifer Nosek, pregnant, smiles in the ocean, in Mexico. (Laurita Polvorilla)Jennifer Nosek, pregnant, smiles in the ocean, in Mexico. (Laurita Polvorilla)

After 2 losing the unborn babies, Jennifer Nosek commemorated her maternity with an infant shower and photoshoot.

Nosek stated she was 40 weeks and 5 days when she began having incorrect labor discomforts on April 11. Her tightenings would certainly launch and after that pick up hours. The following day, she asked Baker to find over and inspect her.

Baker got here around 2, Nosek remembered. Around 3:15 p.m., Baker examined her infant’s heart beat and started rubbing Nosek’s cervix with arnica oil. Nosek stated she really did not really feel any kind of tightenings.

While Lemos had fun with Joaquin in one more space, Nosek stated, Baker offered her a white tablet with a line down the center that could assist relocate points along, explaining it as “a light homeopathic.”

Nosek put the tablet under her tongue.

She remembered Baker stating, “Your infant will certainly be birthed prior to sundown.”

Nosek left the space, remained on the bathroom and scrubed her tummy. After that came a flash of discomfort. She stated she folded up over and sobbed out in misery.

” It resembled a home ablaze,” she remembered.

Nosek stated it was tough to keep an eye on time. Yet she bears in mind seeming like her infant was stuck. Nosek and Lemos stated they both asked Baker whether they must most likely to the healthcare facility, however Baker advised that there had not been adequate time. Lemos stated that then, with his other half in squashing discomfort, he really felt torn. They could leave for the healthcare facility, however suppose something occurred in the process? Inevitably, he stated, he paid attention to Baker. “It was simply disorderly,” he stated.

In her problems, Nosek affirms that Baker seldom utilized her fetal Doppler to inspect the infant’s heart beat. After a preliminary check when Baker got here, Nosek informed NBC Information, Baker examined his heart beat just 4 times after her labor started.

For lower-risk maternities, the American University of Nurse-Midwivesrecommends checking every five minutes when patients are pushing For labor inductions, much more surveillance can be called for. In those instances, medical facilities usually utilize what’s called continual digital fetal surveillance.

Right before 8 p.m. Nosek left the birth swimming pool to rest on the daybed. When Baker held her doppler to Nosek’s stomach, Lemos could not listen to a heart beat via its audio speakers.

The pair affirms Baker, nevertheless, stated she listened to a pale pulse.

Approximately 40 mins later on, Lemos saw as Nosek provided their newborn kid.

He had not been breathing.

Baker, Nosek stated, attempted to resuscitate him.

Lemos called a rescue, however the very first -responders could not resuscitate the infant.

Hours passed as they waited on the coroner. Nosek was still hemorrhaging a great deal, excessive, she assumed. She stressed she could pass away, also. She required to head to the healthcare facility however declined to leave your home if it indicated leaving their infant kid.

” It was the hardest point ever before,” Lemos stated. “You can hold him, kiss him, feel him. He’s still cozy.”

As complete strangers relocated via her home asking inquiries and taking photos, Nosek stated, she was terrified to propose anxiety of just how much blood would certainly drain pipes out of her. Eventually, she stated, Baker offered her a tablet indicated to stem the blood loss.

Prior to she left in a rescue, she required to understand what medicine she was provided after the birth. Nosek stated she saw as Baker jotted down the name of the anti-hemorrhage medicine: misoprostol 200 micrograms.

Later On, as Nosek attempted to assemble what occurred, her mind would certainly take a trip back to that minute and to the tablets she stated she was provided, both prior to and after the birth. They looked similar, she stated, however the very first had actually been referred to as a “natural,” and the 2nd, according to the note she remembered, was misoprostol.

She began to presume she would certainly been provided misoprostol prior to she delivered. When she looked for info concerning the medicine, she discovered a caution that it should not be made use of for labor induction in a mommy that had actually had a previous C-section.

The pair likewise declare that after their kid’s fatality, Baker prompted them not to inform the authorities that she was a midwife or that they would certainly paid her however to determine her just as a good friend. Lemos, stressed that an open examination would certainly postpone the launch of their kid’s body, concurred. There was no postmortem examination, and the infant’s fatality certification states he passed away of perinatal asphyxia, a problem in which an unborn child or baby stops working to obtain sufficient oxygen.

Rene Lemos holds a framed photo  (Jackie Dives for NBC News)Rene Lemos holds a framed photo  (Jackie Dives for NBC News)

Jennifer Nosek with her partner, Rene Lemos, have actually invested the summertime regreting the loss of their newborn kid, Julian Zaire.

3 medical professionals informed NBC Information that if she was provided misoprostol, depending upon the dosage, it can have contributed. Among its most unsafe adverse effects is to possibly decrease an infant’s blood supply, which can restrict an infant’s oxygen.

” It’s past what someone can envision would certainly occur,” Nosek stated. “You understand– it’s not such as something simply failed in my birth and she stopped working to climb to the event. She produced the emergency situation.”


In the weeks that adhered to the fatality of their kid, whom they called Julian Zaire, Joaquin would certainly pat Nosek’s stomach, urging his sibling existed.

” I do not also believe I remained in my body, you understand?” she stated. “I believe I simply divided from myself to endure it.”

Nosek shared her uncertainties with an American midwife that prepared a telephone call with six various other midwives that paid attention to her tale and used their assistance. At the same time, Nosek’s pals in Sayulita started looking into Baker’s previous difficulties in Wisconsin and getting in touch with various other ladies that had actually birthed with her.

Comparable motifs arised. Homeopathics and casts. Labor discomforts that began all of a sudden. Incorrect heart beat surveillance. Births that really felt hurried or postponed to suit Baker’s routine.

In late June, Luciana Suarez’s partner, Thai Shaffer, published a message on Reddit openly sharing claims that Baker had actually provided customers misoprostol without their approval. Baker sent out Suarez a cease-and-desist message in feedback.

In August, in an e-mail to Nosek, the FBI stated meetings were underway. Nosek and Lemos are currently collaborating with a Mexico-based attorney, that is collecting proof in the hope that Mexican district attorneys will certainly bring criminal costs versus Baker.

” What I would love to see is for this to be a darkness that she can not elude,” she stated. “To make sure that everyone recognizes this is her and exactly how she techniques.”

On Salt Springtime Island in British Columbia, there is a memorial yard constructed by Nosek’s mommy devoted to Julian Zaire. It has larkspur, sunflowers and dicentra, frequently called hemorrhaging hearts for the form of their blossoms. This summertime, Nosek has actually hung out there with Lemos and Joaquin.

She reflects to the household’s exclusive seeing on April 19 and a checklist her sis composed for her mommy to check out out loud concerning points Julian would certainly never ever understand.

” The sweet taste of a peach in summertime.”

” The odor of periodontal trees on a warm day.”

Yet Nosek has her very own enhancement to that checklist, one she visualizes informing Julian: “Of all things you’ll never ever understand, possibly the most awful is that you’ll never ever understand exactly how liked you were.”

Nosek and Lemos are working with a Mexico-based lawyer, who is gathering evidence in the hope that Mexican prosecutors will bring criminal charges against Baker. 
 (Jackie Dives for NBC News)Nosek and Lemos are working with a Mexico-based lawyer, who is gathering evidence in the hope that Mexican prosecutors will bring criminal charges against Baker. 
 (Jackie Dives for NBC News)

Nosek and Lemos are collaborating with a Mexico-based attorney, that is collecting proof in the hope that Mexican district attorneys will certainly bring criminal costs versus Baker.

This write-up was initially released on NBCNews.com

.

Check Also

CVS Health and wellness chief executive officer Lynch tips down as nationwide chain battles to right its course

CVS Health And Wellness Chief Executive Officer Karen Lynch has actually tipped down with business …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *